Better Reading

Pages

Wednesday, June 26, 2013

The Roasted Cake Song

There is a Classical Chinese text called the Roasted Cake Song (燒餅歌), supposedly composed by the Ming official Liu Ji (劉基) who was posthumously named Liu Bowen (劉伯溫).  The song is cryptic, and is traditionally held to be prophetic, but is often considered a recent hoax.

I can't comment on whether it is prophetic or not, but I am pretty sure it is not a recent hoax.  Here is a page from the Old Manchu text Jiu Manzhou Dang, detailing a letter sent by the Manchu chieftain Nurhaci to the Khalkha of the Five Encampments in 1620.  I translate the highlighted section below.


The highlighted section says (in Old Manchu):
te geli liobe uwen-i gisunde latunahabi.  tere liobe uwen serengge dūleke julgei [n]iyalma kai. ganio joriha gese. liobe uwen-i gisun ehe sain ojibe emgeli jorime waciha kai.
Which I translate as:
Now again [events] adhere to the words of Liu Bowen.  That Liu Bowen was a person of the ancient past.  It is like he indicated supernatural things.  Regardless of whether his words were of good or evil, what he indicated came to pass.
So, at the very least, we can say that in 1620 there was some text attributed to Liu Bowen that was considered to be strange and prophetic.  It is possible that the Roasted Cake Song that survives to the present day is a hoax, but unless there is something in the content of the surviving text that is clearly anachronistic, we can probably assume that it dates at least to 1620.

No comments:

Post a Comment