Tuesday, July 29, 2014

Tachygraphic systems

I've been reading articles on Tironian notation and what is known about Greek tachygraphy. The most careful discussion of the topic I've come across yet is the article by F. W. G. Float, "On Old Greek Tachygraphy", in the 1901 Journal of Hellenic Studies.

Float points out that different shorthand systems are designed to accomplish different goals: Tachygraphic systems are designed for quick writing; Stenographic systems are meant to preserve space. Either type of system may emphasize clarity or secrecy to some degree.

Tironian notation is simply amazing. Tironian notae encode a modicum of phonetic information--as much as is needed to distinguish a less common word from a more common one--but I would guess that the average nota encodes less phonetic information than the average Chinese character, arguably making the notae tironianae more ideographic than Chinese.

Many of the classical tachygraphic systems seem to encode syllables. In my last post I had said that there were too many symbols in the Rohonc script for it to be a syllabary, but I was thinking of syllabaries that are based on (C)V syllables. For comparison with Latin, where syllables are more complex, I took the book of Genesis from the Vulgata, divided all of the words syllabically, and counted the unique syllables. There were 1139--roughly the same as the number of unique Rohonc symbols. It is not impossible that the Rohonc script could be (partly) syllabic.

Thursday, July 24, 2014

Comparison with Tironian notes

The Rohonc script appears to have on the order of one thousand glyphs. This is far more than one would expect in an alphabet or syllabary, but the most common glyphs are too common to represent morphemes.

It seems there is a relatively small number of core glyphs, some apparent ideograms, and several strategies to extend basic glyphs into more complex ones. These strategies include the addition of new lines and dots (C -> CE); the rotation or reversal of existing glyphs (C -> Q, XD -> XDA); and the use of ligatures (B + CU -> B1CU).

Similar strategies are used in some abugida systems like Ge'ez and Kharosthi, but the historical and geographic context of the Rohonc codex excludes any connection to these systems and their relatives.

I am not aware of any abugida system used in Europe around the 16th century. However, there was a system of scribal shorthand in use up until the 16th century called Tironian notes. Numerous extensions of this system were apparently developed with 1100, 4000, 5000 and 14000 notes.

Like the Rohonc script, Tironian notation has a relatively small number of core marks, extended to more complex marks using similar strategies to the Rohonc script. Indeed, an astonishing number of Tironian notae are similar to or even identical to Rohonc glyphs.

That is not to say that the two systems are the same. The most obvious difference is that the Rohonc script is written right-to-left. In addition, some I can't find Tironian equivalents for some of the most common Rohonc glyphs, and vice-versa.

However, among the writing systems that might have influenced the Rohonc script, Tironian notation has many features that make it a good candidate for further investigation.

Parallel Passages

There are a number of parallel passages in the Rohonc Codex. I came across one last night, and decided to compare the two versions of the passage side-by-side. I was able to identify several glyphs that my current transcription treats as different which should apparently be the same.

I also found an instance of alternate spelling, which may eventually provide some insight into the phonology of some of these glyphs. Compare the following from page 1 R4:

D CX D IX W CO D C3Q L C I CX D CX D C1FR CURE KB

and the following overlapping passage from page 124 R6:

C3Q L I1G CX D CX D C1FR XB KBAD O I CX CUNW

It appears that the word written L C I in the first line is written L I1G in the second line. It is possible that the two words are synonyms, or that the two glyph sequences are similar in sound. Perhaps I1G represents a palatalized form of C in the presence of I (or something like that).

Tuesday, July 22, 2014

Zipf's Law in the Rohonc Codex

I've added a column showing frequencies to the catalog of glyphs that accompanies my in-process transcription of the Rohonc codex.

Of course, the first thing one wants to do with glyph frequencies is to see if Rohoncian obeys Zipf's Law. At first blush, it would seem not, because we have the following distribution for the top ten glyphs:


Glyph Frequency Frequency * Rank
C49524952
I49029804
D381611448
CO298311932
N258812940
O257215432
H165711599
IX153812304
CX140212618
CX1Q8998990

However, this distribution supports something I have suspected already: CO, C and CX are probably the same glyph. I separated them in my transcription because I decided it would be easier to merge glyphs later. But, I suspected that they might be the same because they are apparently interchangeable in the Holy Noun.

If CO, C and CX are merged, then the distribution appears as follows:

Glyph Frequency Frequency * Rank
C, CO, CX93379337
I49029804
D381611448
N258810352
O257212860
H16579942
IX153810766
CX1Q8998990

It's still not perfect, but it is much closer to a normal Zipf distribution.

Monday, July 21, 2014

Rohonc Transcription online (as-is)

My transcription is still only 90% complete. I estimate about 20 more hours of work would be required to finish the remaining 10%, but it is hard for me to find that kind of time.

So rather than let the perfect be the enemy of the good, I have put the transcription online as-is, with the hope that I can continue to refine and update it as I go along.

I have thrown together a website: http://quint.us/Roho. This site is ugly as sin, because I wrote it with an emphasis of function over form. There may well be bugs, but hopefully they are rare. The site provides four basic pieces of functionality:

Download: Download my current revision of the transcription.

Search: Search the transcription.

Browse: Browse the page images and transcription.

Glyphs: View the catalog of glyphs.

As I refine the transcription system and the transcription, I will also work on the site to make it less ugly and more functional. Every time I update the transcription, I will increment the minor revision number. Every time I update the transcription system, I will increment the major revision number.

My system of transcription represents glyphs as strings of capital letters and numbers. The primary goal of the transcription system was to uniquely identify apparently unique glyphs. The secondary goal was to make transcriptions for similar glyphs similar in form. (For example, glyphs whose transcriptions begin with C have shapes that begin with the same semicircular stroke).

When I am less tired, I'll write up a better description of the transcription system.

Happy hunting. I welcome any kind of feedback on the site. Please leave a comment or email me at rst140720@quint.us if you have a suggestion.

Monday, May 12, 2014

Rohonc Transcription 90% done

The last few weeks have been busy for me, both at work and at home. But in my spare time I have managed to push my computer-assisted transcription of the Rohonc codex to 90% completion.

There will be a lot of manual work ahead for the remaining 10%. There are a lot of oddball graphemes, smudges, damaged lines and so forth to dig through. When I am done, I will go back and revise my transcription system, because I have noticed some opportunities for improvement.

Luckily everything is in a huge...thing...that is like a database, but built specifically for this task. When I need to change the transcription, I can do so with a minimum of fuss.

Saturday, May 3, 2014

Meanwhile, in another universe...

I'm still working on the Rohonc transcription, but I thought I would post something amusing and light-hearted for a change.

I've always been bothered by the fact that time seems to only go in one direction, and to be orthogonal to the three spatial dimensions. Somehow it seems...arbitrary.

So imagine a universe where it worked differently: Imagine a four-dimensional universe where time moves outward from a central point, which I'll call the Origin. So, instead of the spatial universe being a three-dimensional slice moving through a four-dimensional space-time, instead it is more like the surface of an expanding hypersphere.

How would light move in a universe like this? If we require that the speed of light be constant in this universe, then the path of light must always be at a constant angle of deflection from a line radiating from the Origin. If the speed of light and the passage of time are constant, then light spirals away from the Origin, always bending at a constant angle of deflection.

What would it be like inside this universe? First, on a small scale, time would appear to be linear, the same way that the Earth appears to be flat, and gravity appears to go in only one direction. Second, on a larger scale, the universe would constantly be expanding.

Now, suppose light is deflected as a result of some influence exerted by the Origin, and that influence decreases the further from the Origin we get. (Maybe inversely proportional to the cube of the distance from the Origin). Since we require that the speed of light be constant, the actual rate of passage of time relative to distance from the origin decreases the farther out we get. Since the size of the universe is proportional to the cube of the distance from the Origin, but time passes increasingly slowly, we would perceive this as an accelerated expansion of the universe.

Chores call, so that's the end of this post.